A sweetener composition containing less than 1 gram of carbohydrates includes a monosaccharide derive polyol such as erythritol, a reduced calorie sweetener such as tagatose, a bulking agent such as polydextrose or maltodextrin and a high intensity, non-nutritive sweetener such as sucralose. The sweetness profile of the sweetener composition may be customized by adjusting the level of high intensity, non-nutritive sweetener included in the compositon.