A method for making a high quality spice sugar cube. The spice sugar cube consists essentially of sugar or a sugar substitute and at least one spice. A quantity of spice and a volume of sugar are measured. A first portion of about one third of the volume of sugar is dissolved in water to create a sugar water solution. The sugar water solution is heated until the solution reaches a temperature between 215 and 235 degrees Fahrenheit resulting in an amount of the water evaporating (e.g., boiling out) from the solution. The solution is than allowed to cool to between 80 and 120 degrees Fahrenheit. The quantity of spice is then mixed into the solution, and then the remaining portion of the volume of sugar is mixed into the solution to form a mixture. The mixture is then poured into a flat pan and pressed to remove any voids and cut into cubes.