A candle extinguisher includes a body of thin-plate, non-combustible material, the body having a ring-shaped part defining an inner space, with an inner diameter at least slightly exceeding the outer diameter of a candle on which the extinguisher is to be positioned. The body has a plurality of flexible finger elements extending upwardly from the ring-shaped part, each of the finger elements having a proximal part and a distal part. The proximal finger parts extend substantially in coplanar relationship with the ring-shaped part and are bendable outwardly relative to the inner space defined by the ring-shaped part. The distal finger parts are bent substantially perpendicularly relative to a respective proximal part and extend inwardly relative to the inner space defined by the ring-shaped part, each of the distal parts having a length exceeding one half of the width of the inner space defined by the ring-shaped part.