Method and apparatus for caching readback data in a cache memory. Upon a transfer of cached readback data to a host device, a cache manager operates to force a retention of the readback data in the cache memory in relation to a time parameter and a locality parameter associated with said data. In this way, the readback data are either retained in hopes of satisfying a subsequent cache hit, or not retained to accommodate subsequently cached data. Preferably, the cache manager compares the time parameter to a time threshold and the locality parameter to a locality threshold, and forces said retention of the readback data if both said thresholds are met. The readback data is preferably associated with a data structure such as a RAID stripe, the time parameter preferably indicates elapsed time since last access to the structure and the locality parameter preferably indicates accesses to the structure.