A puzzle game apparatus includes a substantially rigid game piece including a first plate, a second plate and a third plate. Each of the first, second and third plates has a bottom edge, a top edge, a first lateral edge and a second lateral edge. The top edge of the first and second plates are attached to each other. A bottom edge of the third plate is attached to and extends upwardly from the top edges of the first and second plates. The first plate has a first slot therein. The second plate has a second slot therein extending. A flexible panel has a substantially rectangular shape. A cutting tool is provided and is used for cutting the flexible panel into a plurality of flaps so that the flaps can be bent with respect to each other to mimic an appearance of the game piece.