A pigmented cosmetic composition comprising a water-in-oil emulsion is disclosed. The composition includes a continuous oil phase, an aqueous phase, pigment, emulsifier, and a separation inhibitor comprising a silicone elastomer. The silicone elastomer optionally can be included in a carrier. Also disclosed are a method of inhibiting separation of a pigmented cosmetic composition comprising a water-in-oil emulsion, and a method of preparing a pigmented cosmetic composition.