A method for playing a wagering game includes receiving a wager input from a player for playing a wagering game. In response to receiving the wager input, at least one randomly-selected outcome of a plurality of outcomes is selected, and visual indicia is presented during a first game cycle of the wagering game. The visual indicia is randomly changed to altered visual indicia in a subsequent game cycle of the wagering game, wherein the altered visual indicia provides a fresh look for the subsequent game cycle of the wagering game.