Various methods and systems are disclosed for handling I/O requests to a replica that has not yet been fully synchronized. One method involves detecting the transfer of the role of working volume from a first volume to a second volume. The second volume is configured as a replica of the first volume, but the second volume may not be fully synchronized with the first volume at the time that the role of working volume is transferred. Subsequent to the role of working volume being transferred to the second volume, a read request to the second volume is satisfied by accessing a log. The log is configured to store values that have been written to the first volume, and at least one of the values written to the first volume has not been written to the second volume.