A receptacle (30) having multiple smaller compartments (42) for receiving baby teeth, and a larger compartment (74) for housing a smaller removable receptacle (56) used for placing a baby tooth under a child's pillow. Receptacle (30) comprises a floor (28) with upwardly extending peripheral outer sidewall (34) and slightly shorter partition walls (38) extending from outer sidewall (34) to inner sidewall (36) whose inner periphery forms larger compartment (74). Cover (48) closes the receptacle with a friction fit. Removable digram/date card(82) bears indicia representing twenty baby teeth and a line on which to write date of loss. Shield card (86) allows removal of one tooth for viewing.